It suggests, Nosaka says, that it is the frequency of muscle stimulation that is important, not necessarily the volume of the exercise.
“One contraction a day enough for brain to go ‘OK there’s the stimulus’.”
Muscle strength and mass are an important factor for health, Nosaka says.
“A decrease in muscle mass is a cause of many chronic diseases such as cardiovascular disease, type 2 diabetes, some cancers, dementia, plus musculoskeletal problems such as osteoporosis.”
He adds: “If you maintain muscle mass, you maintain independence and health span.”
Professor Corinne Caillaud, an exercise physiologist at the University of Sydney’s Charles Perkins Centre, says the research is interesting, but adds that the advice to spread our activity across the week is not new.
Loading
“We could think that a similar number of repetitions will produce the same effect whatever the training regime, but this is without accounting for muscle fatigue when doing a larger number of repetitions,” she explains.
This means that the quality of the movement, and muscle work, is superior when the training load is spread over multiple days rather than compressed into one session.
Nosaka’s previous research has found that the type of exercise performed in the study matters. Eccentric muscle contractions, like lowering a kettlebell slowly, the downward phase of a bicep curl, walking downhill or even sitting down very slowly, is better for building strength than concentric contractions.
While they don’t fully understand why, he says we can lower more than we can lift, eccentric exercise fatigues us less, and it engages more of the brain.
“Going down is better to improve muscle function and other parameters for health,” Nosaka says. “It strengthens tendons and ligaments… and myokines [proteins that affect insulin sensitivity and cholesterol] are induced more in eccentric contractions than concentric.”
Caillaud explains that there is research to suggest that eccentric exercise may also lead to quicker muscle adaptations “because this type of muscle contraction is known to generate muscle damage stimulating muscle repair and growth”. However, she says there is the risk of causing too much damage, so she cautions people against doing this type of exercise exclusively.
Rather, adding some eccentric exercise into our day and to our existing physical activity regime can benefit all of us.
Nosaka recommends lifting a heavy dumbbell with two hands, but lowering it slowly with one, sitting down using one leg or sitting into our chairs slowly every time.
“Even when you go to the toilet, you can strengthen your muscles every time you sit down,” says Nosaka, who is in his 60s, plays tennis twice a week and always sits down slowly.
For those not doing any resistance training, this is a good place to start, he says. As for weekend warriors, Nosaka says all exercise “is great”. But, he adds:
“In addition to weekend exercise, do a small amount every day. If you can only find one minute in a day, you can do 20 [three-second muscle contractions]. That can improve strength. That’s very encouraging.”
Make the most of your health, relationships, fitness and nutrition with our Live Well newsletter. Get it in your inbox every Monday.
Discussion about this post